Tony, under the name "Tony316", talks to Cartman on an online chatroom and agrees to meet him at Mel's Buffet the following morning. At Mel's Buffet, Tony gives Cartman some candy and some books on Kama Sutra, but he is arrested by the FBI, who monitored their online chatroom, and is taken to jail. Tony is later shown in jail when Mr. Garrison is arrested as well and tries to give him a back rub.
Tony has short brown hair, brown eyebrows, and a brown mustache. He wears a green shirt with yellow plaid stripes, dark gray pants, and black shoes. He has visible wrinkles on his face.